Why authority can't be faked and what 107 days at Chelsea proved.
Wayne Rooney called him one of the best coaches he'd ever worked with.
Chelsea's players called him the supply teacher.
Both things were true. That's what makes Liam Rosenior's 107 days at Chelsea worth your time this Sunday. Not the result, not the tactics, not the 8-2 aggregate against PSG. The thing underneath all of it.
Authority isn't something you bring with you. It's something a room gives you. And if it doesn't, no amount of effort fills the gap. It usually makes it worse.
The glasses tell the story
There's a detail in the post-mortem reports that I can't stop thinking about.
Rosenior had been wearing glasses on the training ground. At some point he stopped. The reporting suggests he'd become aware of comments about his appearance, so he "ditched the bins" to look tougher. To project something.
That's the moment.
Not the Enzo Fernandez suspension.
Not the PSG humiliation.
Not the goalkeeper rotation.
The glasses.
Because once a manager is making decisions based on how players might be reading him, they've lost. The thinking has already moved from "what does this team need" to "what do they think of me." And teams can sense that gap from a mile off.
Then come the small things. The shift in language. Football365's reporting describes Rosenior leaning into "manager speak" and "LinkedIn language." Players noticed. Inside accounts say he became "too forced," and wasn't "as sure of himself as in January."
Same man. Same CV. Same coaching ability that had Wayne Rooney raving.
But the room had already filed him under "supply teacher," and once that label sticks, every move you make is read through it.
You don't earn authority by performing it
None of you reading this will ever face a Premier League dressing room. But every manager will, at some point, walk into a team that doesn't believe in them yet.
The new hire from outside.
The promoted peer.
The leader brought in over a popular predecessor.
The MD who's just bought the business.
In all of those moments, the temptation is the same as Rosenior's. Project. Perform. Look the part. Talk the talk. Adjust your appearance, your language, your style to match what you think a leader at this level should look like.
It never works.
I've been there myself. I was given responsibility for a team that worked in an area of politics and policy I knew nothing about. The team knew I didn't know anything, they could tell I hadn't really cared about it that much before.
At first I tried to pretend I knew what I was talking about. That didn't work.
So then I thought I'd give the team plenty of autonomy and control over decisions as they knew better than me. That didn't work either.
Both things massively undermined my authority.
It wasn't until I owned what I didn't know, and got their input, but identified the areas where I could definitely help them that I started to make some ground and have an impact.
The room can always tell.
The three things authority is actually made of
Authority isn't a posture. It's a deposit account. You make deposits before you make withdrawals. Three things go in:
Competence. Are you visibly good at the thing the team is being asked to do? Not perfect. Not all-knowing. But credibly capable, and willing to show your working. Rosenior was a good coach. But "good coach at Strasbourg" doesn't translate, untested, to "authority in a Champions League dressing room." Taking risks that don't pay off too early can destroy trust in your competence.
Consistency. Do you behave the same way on a Tuesday as you do on a Saturday? Do players know what you'll do before you do it? Rosenior's tactics changed mid-match. His language changed. His glasses came off. The signal to the room was someone trying to be something, not someone being it.
Relationships. Do the people you lead actually know you? Not in a friendship way. In a "I know what this person values, and I trust them when it counts" way. Rosenior couldn't read his own dressing room's factional dynamics. The Spanish speakers, the Maresca loyalists, the political fault lines. He couldn't read them because he hadn't built the relationships that would let him.
Make the deposits, you can spend. Skip the deposits and try to spend anyway, you get the Fernandez suspension. Right call. No fuel in the tank to back it. Sacked.
What managers can take from this
Look at the way you walked into your last role. Or the way you'll walk into the next one. The instinct will be to act like the person the role demands. Talk like them. Dress like them. Email like them.
Resist it. The room doesn't need a performance. It needs to see you.
Be visibly good at one or two things in the first month. That's competence.
Behave the same way in the meeting and out of it. That's consistency.
Have a real conversation with every person who reports to you, where you ask more than you tell. That's the relationship.
Authority builds quietly out of those three. Try to fake it and you'll be the supply teacher inside a fortnight.
Rosenior took his glasses off to look harder. He should have kept them on.
Have a great week.
|
|
Arran Russell
Founder, Set The Tone
|
Ps. I've had some free spaces come available on my Foundations Programme starting on 12th May as at least one company is now doing something bespoke with me. Details of the programme are here in the onboarding pack. If you're interested at all, reply to this email, and let's have a chat.
