Napoleon had the best army in Europe. Britain had better managers.
Britain won.
I read Dominic Cummings' notes on Roger Knight's book Britain Against Napoleon: The Organisation of Victory recently. The subtitle is the giveaway. Not "the story of victory." The organisation of victory.
Knight's argument is that we've been telling ourselves the wrong story about the Napoleonic Wars for 200 years. The version most people know is Wellington, Nelson, Trafalgar, Waterloo. Great men doing great things on battlefields. And that stuff mattered. But it's not why Britain won.
Britain won a 22-year war against a regime that, at its peak, commanded many times Britain's resources and manpower. It survived multiple changes of government and the assassination of a prime minister. It did this while one in six eligible British men served in the armed forces and the entire population lived under genuine fear of invasion.
How? Not through battlefield genius alone. Through organisation. Supply chains. Procurement. Logistics. Tax reform. Manufacturing capacity. Communications infrastructure. The boring stuff.
The heroes of Knight's book aren't generals and admirals. They're civil servants, administrators, and what he calls the "silent men of business." And many of them were young. John Herries was 24 when he became Commissary-in-Chief to the army. Henry Bunbury was 25 when he became Under-Secretary of War. These weren't seasoned veterans given safe roles. They were talented people put into positions of real responsibility because the situation demanded it.
The state recognised that it needed to stop appointing people based on patronage and start selecting on skill. That civil servants needed proper pay, proper working conditions, and dramatically longer hours. That efficiency should be measured by output, not cost. That the armed forces needed feeding, equipping, paying, and their families needed supporting, and all of it had to be managed as a system.
What managers can take from this
Tbh, there are loads of lessons from this book, a few to call out are:
Put your best people in the right roles, regardless of age or seniority. Herries and Bunbury didn't get their jobs because they'd waited their turn. They got them because they were the right people. Britain couldn't afford to waste talent on hierarchy or because of tenure. Most growing businesses can't either, but they do it anyway.
Train relentlessly. The British state invested heavily in building capability at every level. It had to. The system they inherited in the 1790s was a mess. Office staff starting work at 11 and leaving at four. Basic administrative tasks neglected. They rebuilt it through deliberate investment in people. 82% of UK managers today have no formal management training. EU countries invest roughly double what we do per employee. We've decided training is a nice-to-have. The people who beat Napoleon treated it as the foundation.
Plan. Not just operations. Strategic planning. What's coming, what we'll need, how to get ahead of it. The British state had to think years ahead while fighting a war that changed shape constantly. Most managers spend all their time in the weeds and never step back to ask what their team needs to look like in six months. If you're always firefighting, you never prevent fires.
Learn from mistakes, systematically. When things went wrong, and they did, the British investigated why. Not to assign blame. To learn and adapt. The Walcheren expedition of 1809 was a disaster. 4,000 dead, mostly from disease. But the inquiry and reforms that followed it made the system better. Most organisations lose a customer or mess up a project and just make excuses. The ones that get better are the ones that treat failure as data.
The fundamentals of running things well haven’t changed in 200 years. Talent in the right roles. Training. Planning. Learning from what goes wrong.
Knight’s book is called The Organisation of Victory for a reason. Victory wasn’t just won. It was organised. By people who took the boring stuff seriously.
Arran
|
|
Arran Russell
Founder, Set The Tone
|
Ps:
